Supreme Court of Canada clarifies the test for causation in tort claims

In Hemmings v. Padmore, 2026 SCC 34, The Supreme Court of Canada clarified the law regarding causation of injuries in a medical negligence claim. The plaintiff suffered a cardiac arrest during an emergency caesarean section, resulting in permanent brain damage. At trial, the defendants who were found liable included the plaintiff’s primary obstetrician throughout her pregnancy but not the delivery, the on-duty hospital anesthesiologist during delivery, and a hospital nurse who the plaintiff consulted 10 days before delivery. On appeal, the actions against the obstetrician and hospital were dismissed, while the claim against the anesthesiologist was upheld.

The claim against the obstetrician related to pre-delivery failures to administer an earlier pregnancy test, advise the plaintiff of medical risks associated with her pregnancy, and advise the plaintiff of the option of abortion. The claim against the nurse related to her failure to review the plaintiff’s clinical records and advise the plaintiff to seek medical attention when the plaintiff called the hospital 10 days before her delivery. The claim against the anesthesiologist related to his failure to try to calm the plaintiff before converting to a general anesthetic, and his intubation of the plaintiff. The court ultimately held that the plaintiff’s injuries were too remote from the conduct of both the obstetrician and nurse to hold either liable.

The court clarified the test for causation. First, the court must determine whether the defendant’s conduct was the factual cause of the plaintiff’s injuries (factual causation). Second, the court must determine whether the plaintiff’s injuries are too remote from the defendant’s conduct to assign liability (remoteness of damages). Only factual causation addresses a strictly causal question. Remoteness is a normative inquiry into whether there is a sufficient connection between the defendant’s wrongful conduct and the plaintiff’s injuries such that the defendant should be liable. The court preferred the term “remoteness” over historical references to “legal causation”, “proximate cause”, “proximity” or “cause-in-law”.

Factual causation applies the “but for” test. The plaintiff must show on a balance of probabilities that, but for the defendant’s negligent act, the injury would not have occurred. This test requires that the defendant’s conduct was a necessary cause of the plaintiff’s injury, but not necessarily the sole cause. In considering factual causation, the court should apply the test in a robust, common sense fashion that considers all the evidence. The burden remains with the plaintiff to prove factual causation, although a defendant may rebut an inference of causation by introducing evidence demonstrating that the injury would have occurred regardless of their negligent conduct. If the plaintiff’s injury would not have occurred but for the defendant’s negligent conduct, it must also be true that, if the defendant’s conduct had met the standard of care, the plaintiff’s injury would not have occurred.

Remoteness involves several principles. First, a negligent defendant can only be liable for those consequences that they could have reasonably foreseen at the time of their breach and from their vantage point. Second, for the plaintiff’s injury to be reasonably foreseeable, there must have been a real risk or probability, one greater than a mere possibility, that the type of injury could occur. The risk must be sufficient in that a reasonable person in the defendant’s position would not brush it off as far-fetched and would have taken reasonable precautions to prevent it. The type of accident needs to have been foreseeable, but not the particular circumstances of the accident.

The inquiry of “real risk” or probability of injury must be appreciated in light of the corrective justice orientation of tort law. A defendant can only be liable for the plaintiff’s injuries if the probability that those injuries would occur was something the defendant ought to have considered and taken precautions to prevent, having regard to the degree of harm and the costs associated with preventing the risk of that harm.

Reasonable foreseeability plays a different role in establishing a duty of care and determining whether the plaintiff’s injuries are too remote. The duty of care analysis is aimed at establishing a sufficient link between the defendant’s wrongful conduct and the “type of injury”. In the remoteness inquiry, the question of reasonable foreseeability is focused on whether “the actual injury suffered by the plaintiff” was reasonably foreseeable to the defendant.